• A vision of what the beach could be, based on engineering descriptions.
    The Memorial Beach Vision
    A vision of what Kaimana Beach could be...
  • An aerial view of the Natatorium as it exists today.
    The Crumbling Natatorium
    ...the Natatorium in 2004...
  • The Crumbling Natatorium
    ...the Natatorium in 2012. Image: Google Maps
  • A rendering of what the Memorial could be. Image from the City & County of Honolulu.
    The Memorial Beach Vision
    Image: City & County of Honolulu
  • A rendering of what the beach could be. Image from the City & County of Honolulu.
    The Memorial Beach Vision
    Image: City & County of Honolulu

Column: Appalling neglect of Kaimana Beach


Published in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser Editoral/Island Voices section
June 26, 2022
By Nancie Caraway

“We see brown everywhere, not much green, smelly garbage cans, bare patches in grass, cracked and broken steps, dry water fountains, slimy cement, pools of fetid standing water, rusted pipes, an unsanitary and unhygienic wasteland.”

No, those words aren’t the logline for a post-apocalyptic movie. They come from my Kaimana Beach notebook dating back more than a decade. One entry stands out. In a conversation with then-Honolulu Mayor Peter Carlisle (2010-2013), I shared my observations about the beach. His reply, “If you want to clean up this mess, you pay for it.” A disheartening exchange, I’m sure, for both of us.

But it does demonstrate the emotion and frustration that pit public policies and priorities against our reverence for place. For the human yearning for a regenerative connection with the natural world. Hawaiian indigenous wisdom is grounded in a primal and spiritual connection to specific places. Kaimana Beach is one such place. Its history, its genealogy, its awe-inspiring proximity to Diamond Head (Mount Leahi).

‘Aina is not just ocean or land — but a heart issue for Hawaiians. Environmental scientists value the holism and sustainability of these principles today more than ever.

The conditions at this beloved beach demoralize local people, taxpayers, who have watched it degenerate. Don’t our families deserve the clean and beautiful beaches our unsustainable tourists enjoy? It truly does hurt our hearts.

Kaimana Beach marks milestones in my life. A place for making memories. As a University of Hawaii-Manoa graduate student, I hauled my books there and slogged through Hegel and Plato. I enjoyed bento and talk-story with friends who reveled in being together sharing glorious sunsets and swims. I grieved when ashes were spread in waves taking the spirits of loved ones back to nature.

Why have efforts to preserve the special ambiance of the last local beach in Honolulu stalled through the years? A survey of the numerous task forces, environmental impact statements, resolutions, scientific and architectural plans, surpasses the limits of this commentary.

Consider the overlapping interests — the Waikiki Natatorium War Memorial organizations, city agencies, Diamond Head Neighborhood Board, state Historic Preservation Division, park users, commercial businesses — which have complicated compromise. And thwarted the efforts of four previous mayors and City Councils.

Flash forward to June 2022. Mayor Rick Blangiardi and the City Council now inherit this negligence. Council Chairman Tommy Waters (whose district includes Kaimana Beach) reports that the city Department of Facility Maintenance has been awarded $1 million in fiscal year 2022 specifically to “plan, design and construct shower improvements for Kaimana Beach Park.” This is a welcome and long-overdue solution to the rusted pipe that now serves as a “shower.”

Any crumb from the city to enhance Kaimana is good news. Critics might add that it’s too little too late. What about the disgraceful rotting of the Natatorium with its elegant arch, long-shuttered and hidden by fences and parked cars? Might it be honored at another more fitting locale? Then there are the picnic areas with dirt patches on spare grass and little shade. And surely the Health Department would disapprove of the fetid standing water and broken drinking fountain near the Diamond Head entrance to the beach.

Blangiardi recently signed the budget. We ask him for the broadest interpretation of “plan, design and construct shower improvements” to include landscape and regenerate the entire area adjacent to the beach.

Do we still feel joy when we visit the beach? Of course. And a grateful public says “mahalo nui loa” to the officials and advocates for their efforts over the years. But now is the time for decisive leadership to restore the last remaining beach on Oahu’s south shore. This is a sacred trust broken too many times.

Our commitment remains to the mission of the Kaimana Beach Coalition, a nonprofit founded by ocean-lover Rick Bernstein in 1990: “To protect this precious beach from commercialization, environmental degradation and to assure public access to this nurturing gathering place.”

Nancie Caraway, Ph.D., is a political scientist and advocate, and a former first lady of Hawaii.



Ocean-water pool is part of Waikiki Natatorium restoration EIS

The long debate over the future of the Waikiki War Memorial Natatorium may finally be over. The deteriorating facility — opened in 1927 as a monument to Hawaii residents who served during World War I, but closed in 1979 due to disrepair — would be rehabilitated by the city as an operational, open circulation saltwater pool, according to the city’s preferred “perimeter deck” option outlined in the final Environmental Impact Statement released to the public Friday.
Continue Reading →

Kaimana Beach Coalition Comments on the Draft EIS

The Kaimana Beach Coalition's official comments on the October 2018 Draft EIS.
Continue Reading →

The Conversation: Friday, December 21st, 2018 (Excerpt)

December 21, 2018 - Catherine Cruz: Just days before deadline for public input, we're learning more about the preferred alternative to the future of the Waikiki War Memorial Natatorium. State Health Director Bruce Anderson, who grew up swimming in the pool, talks to us about his concerns about the proposed deck. Shoring the structure up may mean driving scores of pilings 65 feet into the reef, and he has concerns about silt in the pool affecting the marine conservation district next door.
Continue Reading →

The Conversation: Remembering The Past and A Look To The Future Of Waikiki (Excerpts)

December 20, 2018 - On The Conversation on Hawaii Public Radio, Andrew Rossiter, Director of the Waikiki Aquarium, and Dolan Eversole, a coastal geologist with the University of Hawaii's Sea Grant college, share their views on the potential "catastrophic" impacts of the natatorium's perimeter deck plan.
Continue Reading →

The Conversation: Waikiki Natatorium Draft Environmental Impact Statement

Christmas is coming up fast, but even faster is a deadline to submit your two cents about the future of the Waikiki Natatorium War Memorial. We invited Robert Kroning, the city's Design and Construction Director, to stop by yesterday afternoon to talk about the EIS and the modified deck option.
Continue Reading →